AEC pastoral letter offers guidance on sexual and gender identity

The Antilles Episcopal Conference (AEC) has issued its first pastoral letter specifically addressing sexual and gender identity, with Bishop Robert Llanos saying the document is intended to provide families, educators and Church institutions with a reliable Catholic resource for navigating increasingly prominent questions surrounding these issues.

Speaking during an interview on Altos, Bishop Llanos explained that the pastoral letter emerged from the work of the AEC’s Family and Life Commission, which continually considers developments affecting family life throughout the Caribbean. Bishop Llanos chairs the Commission. The bishops, he said, have a responsibility to remain attentive to what families are encountering and to provide appropriate pastoral guidance.

“We are always on our toes, so to speak, to see what kind of issues are happening in the world, what’s going on in the world around us, and how we may fulfil our responsibility to be shepherds of the Catholic family and the children of God,” he said.

This includes examining current trends and the challenges parents face in raising their children within the Christian faith. Recognising the questions emerging globally around sexual and gender identity, the bishops determined that a specific Caribbean pastoral response was necessary.

A reliable Catholic resource

Bishop Llanos confirmed that this is the first AEC document devoted specifically to sexual and gender identity, describing the subject as “a very prominent issue right now”.

He said the bishops were concerned about what they regarded as threats to human dignity and believed the Church had a responsibility to address areas of confusion, misunderstanding and misidentification.

“We see a threat to the dignity of the human person,” Bishop Llanos said. “And we feel a responsibility to clarify the areas of confusion and misidentification and misunderstanding.”

One of the difficulties, he suggested, is the sheer amount of information available through social media. While people now have access to thousands of sources, he cautioned that some of the information being circulated may be erroneous, incomplete or misleading.

Against this background, the AEC wanted Catholics and other Christians to have a resource whose content they could trust.

The intention, he explained, was to produce something grounded in “good theological understanding, good scientific research, good Christian anthropology” and other relevant areas of study.

The document is therefore not intended solely for bishops, priests or theologians. Bishop Llanos said it was designed for practical use by those encountering questions of sexuality and gender in families, schools, parishes and other institutions serving children and young people.

From document to discussion

With the pastoral letter now published, attention is turning towards how its teaching will reach Catholics across the region.

Bishop Llanos said the document has been sent to all bishops of the AEC, together with recommendations for its use within individual dioceses.

Among those specifically identified as potential users are teachers, parents, lawmakers, policymakers and those responsible for institutions where young people are under their care.

The hope, he said, is that dioceses will use their own media and pastoral structures to disseminate the document widely. More importantly, the bishops want it to become a subject of discussion within Catholic institutions.

Bishop Llanos said it should be discussed among school principals, teachers, priests, catechists, and others involved in formation. Parents will necessarily become an important part of that conversation.

Once catechists, principals, teachers and students begin engaging with the document, Bishop Llanos predicted that parents would naturally become involved and begin asking practical questions about how they should respond to situations affecting their children.

“The parents are going to come in,” he said. “Have to come in and want to know…what do we do?”

The pastoral letter seeks to help answer precisely those questions. Bishop Llanos pointed particularly to Chapter Four and the appendix, which contain pastoral guidelines and general directives for responding to situations involving sexual and gender identity. These sections also provide guidance for policymakers and other leaders on how the document can be used.

The final section takes an especially practical approach, presenting questions and answers that may arise when, for example, a parent approaches a catechist or teacher seeking guidance.

Bishop Llanos said the inclusion of these resources means the pastoral letter goes beyond simply stating the Church’s position. “We have very clear guidelines of what can be done with it,” he said.

The challenge now is to ensure that the pastoral letter moves beyond publication and becomes a working resource within Caribbean Catholic families, schools, parishes and institutions—providing a basis for informed discussion and pastoral accompaniment as parents and young people encounter increasingly complex questions about sexuality, identity and human dignity.

Assisted generation using ChatGPT.ai